Ask five different regulars at Maurice’s Piggie Park which burger is the best, and you’ll get five different answers argued with total conviction. That’s not an accident.
Every burger on our menu starts the same way: hand-shaped, fresh-ground beef, grilled fresh to order, so the debate isn’t about quality. It’s about which topping combination fits your mood. Here’s how the four contenders stack up.
The Original: Hamburger & Cheeseburger
Before you can pick a favorite, you have to start here. Our classic Hamburger is the one folks in Columbia have been calling one of the best burgers in town for years, and it’s the same burger that landed us in Garden & Gun magazine’s reader poll for The South’s Best Burgers back in 2014.
Add a slice of cheese, and it becomes the Cheeseburger, the standard against which the other three get measured. If you’ve never had it, start here before you branch out.
The Crowd-Pleaser: Bacon Cheeseburger
This is the safest bet on the list, and there’s no shame in that. Crispy bacon and melted cheese on our hand-formed patty is the order that is sure to be a winner. If you’re bringing someone new to Piggie Park and you’re not sure what they’ll like, this is the one to steer them toward.
The Local Favorite: Chili Cheeseburger
Our old-fashioned homemade chili turns a regular cheeseburger into something heartier, and this is the burger that shows up in conversation most often among regulars who grew up eating at our Columbia-area locations. It’s messy in the best way. Use extra napkins.
The Southern Curveball: Pimento Cheeseburger
This is the one that surprises out-of-towners and delights everyone else. We top the burger with our homemade pimento cheese, now available at all of our locations, for a creamy, tangy finish that’s about as Southern as it gets. If you already love pimento cheese, this burger will probably win the debate for you outright.
So, Which One Actually Wins?
Honestly, that’s the point; there isn’t a wrong answer. The Cheeseburger is the benchmark that earned the Garden & Gun nod, the Bacon Cheeseburger is the crowd-pleaser, the Chili Cheeseburger is the local’s pick, and the Pimento Cheeseburger is the Southern specialty you won’t find everywhere. The only way to actually settle the debate is to work through all four.
Try Them for Yourself
All four burgers are grilled fresh to order at every Maurice’s Piggie Park location across the Columbia area, from West Columbia and Irmo to Downtown Columbia, Devine Street, Northeast Columbia, and Lexington.
Stop by, order your favorite (or start the argument all over again), and see why folks keep calling these the best burgers in Columbia, SC.




